Recently, I attended the ASCAP NY Sessions and spent a day immersed in conversations about how songwriters are making a living in a changing music industry. A few observations kept coming up throughout the day. One came from Rob Thomas of Matchbox Twenty during his opening interview.
Rob talked about how, whether you’re a major-label artist or someone writing songs in a bedroom, you have to be committed to writing a great song. That sounds simple enough. But it takes a willingness to scrutinize your own work and admit when you can do better.
Another panelist, Casey McPherson of Alpha Rev, spoke about his journey in music. At the time, Casey had recently signed with Hollywood Records, a Disney subsidiary, and was a remarkably prolific lyricist. During the discussion, the producer working on Alpha Rev’s upcoming album recalled a conversation with Casey about his writing process.
One line stuck with me. The producer, Jason, said he had called Casey and asked, “So, what did you do today?” Casey replied, “Wrote ten songs.” Jason asked, “Any of ’em good?” Casey answered, “Nope.”
That exchange was startling. Most of us would be thrilled to write one, two, or ten songs in a day. But would we feel the same way if we were holding ourselves to a higher standard?
So what is the standard?
The good news—and the frustrating news—is that there isn’t a single formula. We can study song structures, memorable hooks, builds, and releases. But ultimately, the challenge is to write something emotionally true that connects with other people.
I believe one of the best ways to get there is to study the songs you love, especially those that have stood the test of time. Break them down. Understand what makes them work. Then put the analysis aside and write. And write. And write some more.
Over time, that combination of study, honest self-assessment, and repetition can become part of your instincts. The goal isn’t simply to finish more songs. It’s to keep developing the judgment and craft to recognize—and write—a great one.